Almost everyone in panic is told to take deep breaths, and it is close to the opposite of what helps. Understanding why turns breathing from a frustrating instruction into the most reliable tool available during an attack.
The problem is too much air
Anxious breathing is fast and shallow, drawn from the upper chest. Breathing above what the body needs clears too much carbon dioxide from the blood.
Low carbon dioxide narrows blood vessels slightly and makes it harder for oxygen to move from the blood into the tissues. That produces the tingling, dizziness, air hunger and sense of unreality. Oxygen levels remain normal throughout, which is why gulping more air changes nothing.
Why deep breaths backfire
A large in-breath adds more air to a system already carrying too much and pushes carbon dioxide lower still. There is often a second of relief followed by a worsening of the symptoms.
The same applies to repeated yawning and sighing, both of which feel like attempts to satisfy the breath and quietly perpetuate the imbalance.
Extend the out-breath
This is the core technique and it is deliberately simple. Breathe in through the nose for a count of four, then out through the mouth for a count of six or seven.
Keep the breaths small. The aim is to slow the rate and lengthen the exhalation, not to move more air. A longer out-breath also activates the branch of the nervous system that lowers heart rate, so it works on two mechanisms at once.
Breathe with the belly
Place one hand on the chest and one on the stomach. During anxious breathing the upper hand moves and the lower barely does. Reversing that is the goal.
Diaphragmatic breathing is more efficient, uses the muscles designed for the job, and stops overworking the small muscles around the neck and collarbones that produce chest tightness after a long day of it.
Square breathing for people who lose count
Some people find the counting itself stressful during an attack. Square breathing gives a simpler rhythm: in for four, hold for four, out for four, hold for four.
The hold slows the overall rate, which is the active ingredient. If holding feels alarming, drop it and return to the simple long exhalation.
What to avoid
Do not breathe into a paper bag. It is outdated advice and genuinely risky if the cause turns out not to be over-breathing.
Avoid checking whether the technique is working every few seconds, which turns it into another form of monitoring. Set a rough intention to breathe this way for a few minutes and let it run.
Practise when you are calm
This is the part that gets skipped, and it is why people conclude that breathing techniques do not work for them. A technique attempted for the first time mid-attack will fail, because it is competing with a well-established automatic pattern.
Five minutes on ordinary days, repeated over a fortnight, makes it available under pressure. Practising while mildly uncomfortable, such as during a queue or a difficult email, bridges the gap to using it during an attack.
What breathing will not do
It reduces the physical intensity of an attack and shortens the tail. It does not address the fear of attacks, and it does not stop them recurring.
Used as a way of forcing panic to stop, it becomes another safety behaviour and quietly maintains the cycle. Used as a way of getting through something you are willing to let happen, it helps.
Why counting does more than regulate the breath
Part of the benefit of a counted rhythm has nothing to do with carbon dioxide. Counting occupies working memory, which is the same resource being used to run catastrophic predictions about what the symptoms mean.
This is one reason the technique works better than simply being told to breathe slowly. It gives attention a defined task at exactly the moment attention would otherwise be scanning the body. If counting feels difficult, tracing the outline of your fingers in time with the breath achieves the same thing.
This is general information rather than medical advice. If panic attacks are recurring, speak to your GP about treatment options.