Sleeping tablets do produce sleep, which is why they are prescribed. The difficulty is that chronic insomnia is a long-term problem and these are short-term medicines, and the gap between those two facts causes most of the trouble.
What is prescribed
The main hypnotics used in the UK are the so-called z-drugs, including zopiclone and zolpidem, and benzodiazepines such as temazepam.
Both act on the same system in the brain, enhancing the activity of GABA, the main inhibitory neurotransmitter.
Some sedating antidepressants and antihistamines are also used, and melatonin is covered separately.
Why prescribing is short-term
UK guidance recommends hypnotics for short-term use only, typically no more than a few weeks, and at the lowest effective dose.
The reasons are tolerance, dependence and rebound insomnia, all of which develop reasonably quickly.
Tolerance
The effect diminishes with continued use, so the same dose produces less sleep. This can happen within weeks.
The natural response is to increase the dose, which restores the effect temporarily and accelerates the process.
Dependence
Both physical and psychological dependence can develop. Physical dependence means withdrawal effects on stopping. Psychological dependence means a belief that sleep is impossible without the tablet, which is frequently the harder part.
People who have taken hypnotics for years commonly describe being unable to contemplate a night without one, regardless of how well it works.
Rebound insomnia
On stopping, sleep is frequently worse than before the tablets were started, for a period.
This is a withdrawal effect rather than the original insomnia returning, and it is temporary. It is also the main reason people restart, since the rebound is taken as proof that the medication was necessary.
Side effects worth knowing
Daytime drowsiness and impaired concentration, which can persist into the following day.
Impaired coordination and increased risk of falls, which matters particularly in older adults. Effects on memory. Reduced driving performance, which can persist the morning after.
Complex sleep behaviours, where people carry out activities while not fully awake and with no memory of it, are uncommon and recognised.
Combining hypnotics with alcohol or with opioids is dangerous and should be avoided.
Over-the-counter options
Sedating antihistamines are sold for sleep and have limited evidence for insomnia. Tolerance develops quickly, and they commonly produce next-day grogginess.
They have anticholinergic effects, which are a particular concern in older adults.
Herbal products including valerian are widely sold, and the evidence is weak.
Where tablets are reasonable
Short-term insomnia with a clear trigger, such as bereavement or an acute crisis, where a few nights of sleep would help someone cope.
Situations where CBT-I is not immediately available and someone is not functioning.
Used deliberately and briefly, they are a reasonable tool. Used indefinitely by default, they become the problem.
Stopping safely
Do not stop suddenly if you have been taking hypnotics regularly for a long period, since abrupt withdrawal from benzodiazepines in particular can be dangerous. Reduction should be gradual and planned with your prescriber.
Withdrawal is considerably easier alongside CBT-I, since the psychological dependence is addressed at the same time.
What to do if you have taken them for years
A great many people are on long-term hypnotics that were originally prescribed for a few weeks, and feel stuck with them.
This is common and it is addressable. Ask for a medication review and a planned reduction alongside CBT-I rather than attempting to stop alone. Reduction schedules are usually slow and the psychological dependence is treated at the same time.
Older adults in particular
Hypnotics carry greater risks with age. Sensitivity increases, the drugs are cleared more slowly, and the consequences of falls are considerably more serious.
Sedating antihistamines sold over the counter carry additional anticholinergic effects that are a specific concern in older adults. Long-term prescribing in this group is discouraged for these reasons, and reviewing it is worthwhile.
What to ask for instead
CBT for insomnia is the recommended first-line treatment and is more effective over the long term. Ask about it specifically.
This is general information rather than medical advice and does not cover doses or full prescribing information. Discuss any medication with your prescriber or pharmacist.