People frequently expect therapy to produce steady improvement and are alarmed when the opposite happens. Feeling worse for a period is common, and it has several different causes, some expected and some not.
Approaching what you avoid
The most common reason and generally a sign of progress.
Avoidance reduces distress in the short term, which is why people do it. Therapy involves approaching what has been avoided, whether a memory, a situation or a feeling.
Distress rising initially is therefore expected. In exposure-based treatments it is the mechanism rather than a side effect.
Feelings that were suppressed
People who have been managing by not feeling things frequently find that therapy restores access to the feelings.
Numbness is uncomfortable and is also protective. Losing it means experiencing grief, anger or fear that had been held at a distance, sometimes for years.
This is progress that feels like deterioration.
The session hangover
Feeling drained, tearful or preoccupied for a day or two after a session is extremely common.
Sessions frequently open something that then continues processing between appointments, which is why the day after is sometimes harder than the session itself.
Planning something undemanding afterwards helps considerably, and most people schedule therapy without any thought to what follows it.
Seeing things you had not seen
Therapy frequently produces recognitions that are unwelcome: that a relationship is not working, that a job is untenable, or that something in childhood was not normal.
These are accurate perceptions arriving rather than the therapy causing harm, and they are frequently followed by grief.
The improvement that reveals the problem
As people become less depressed, they sometimes notice their circumstances more clearly, and gain enough energy to be angry about them.
This can look like deterioration and is frequently the opposite.
When it indicates a problem
Not all of it is expected, and some of it warrants changing something.
Pace that is too fast, particularly with trauma. Being pushed to describe something before stabilisation is in place can be destabilising rather than therapeutic.
An approach that does not fit the difficulty. Sustained deterioration over months rather than fluctuation.
Feeling consistently criticised, judged or blamed by the therapist.
Being left with intense distress at the end of sessions with no time to settle, which is a fault in how sessions are structured.
Signs that need immediate attention
New or increased thoughts of ending your life or of self-harm. Being unable to function between sessions. Feeling unsafe.
Tell your therapist, and contact your GP. Samaritans are on 116 123 at any hour, or text SHOUT to 85258. Call 111 and choose the mental health option, or 999 if there is immediate risk.
Raising it
Say it plainly. Describe what has been happening between sessions rather than only how you feel in the room, since the therapist cannot see that.
A competent therapist will take it seriously, and the response tells you whether to continue.
What should change
Slowing the pace. Spending time on stabilisation and coping skills before continuing with difficult material.
Structuring sessions so that the last part is used to settle rather than ending at peak distress.
Agreeing what to do between sessions if distress becomes difficult.
Involving a GP where risk has increased.
Telling people close to you
Where therapy is producing difficult weeks, those around you will notice without knowing why.
Explaining briefly that you are working on something and may be more tired or emotional for a period prevents it being misread, and frequently produces more support than trying to conceal it.
The non-linear pattern
Improvement in therapy is rarely a steady line, and expecting one causes unnecessary alarm.
The usual pattern is fluctuation within an overall direction, with bad weeks inside an improving trend.
Judging progress month to month rather than week to week gives a considerably more accurate picture, which is one reason services use repeated questionnaires.
Do not simply stop
Disengaging silently at this point is common and leaves you worse off, with something opened and nothing done to close it.
Where you do want to stop, an ending session to consolidate what has happened is considerably better than disappearing.
This is general information rather than medical advice.